Tchaikovsky, Eugene Onegin, 1879
Friday 3rd & 10th November
Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky
Born in 1840, he was one of the first students at the newly
founded St. Petersburg Conservatory. He married in 1877,
to escape the stigma of homosexuality; weeks later left his
wife, attempted suicide and fled abroad. He died in 1893,
possibly by suicide. In his short and sad life he had
composed 169 pieces, including symphonies, operas,
ballets, concertos, cantatas and songs, and he rapidly
became the best known Russian composer.
(Biography.com)
Listen to ClassicFm’s fast guide here.
It seems to me that I am truly gifted with the ability
truthfully, sincerely, and simply to express the feelings,
moods, and images suggested by a text. In this sense I am
a realist and fundamentally a Russian. - Tchaikovsky
(Opera101)
Whose Onegin?
The composer resisted, then swiftly adopted the
idea of an opera from Pushkin’s poem. The
interesting question is why did he resist? His
version is a very simple story with an ending fitting
his own depression, but unlikely to please romantic
audiences (it didn’t, and Tchaikovsky changed it
twice.) Not popular in his lifetime, it’s now credited
with being the perfect opera – so what’s changed?
Onegin has everything: breathtaking music, heartrending
poetry, and the drama of passionate characters who live
and breathe as we do. Like an apparition from the past,
once heard this beautiful opera haunts our dreams.
(Oliver Mears of Scottish Opera) But it doesn’t
have Pushkin’s irony and wit – compare to the
original here.
Leitmotif Russian style
Tchaikovsky advances a leitmotif-like structure
spanning outward from Tatyana’s Letter Scene, the
centrepiece of the opera. This isn’t Wagner by any
means but you’ll hear the same recurring themes
throughout, ever shifting towards the final climactic
duet. (Opera101)
Tchaikovsky’s deep sympathy for his heroine Tatyana is
shown in the tenderness of her music. Her yearning
string motif opens the opera and it gains full
expression in her letter aria in Act I – one of the most
intense solo scenes ever written for the soprano voice.
(ROH)
The social commentary
“Thus heaven’s gift to us is this:/ That habit
takes the place of bliss.” Tatyana’s mother’s aria
comes straight from Pushkin. The isolation and
the constraints of their estate life contrast with
the self-indulgent, bored words of Onegin, come
from ‘society’ to the country.
At a time when other Russian composers were
preoccupied with grand, public opera plots that drew
from Russian history and mythology, Tchaikovsky took
the risk of moving in the opposite direction – into the
intimate, private world of Eugene Onegin…Tchaikovsky
shaped Onegin’s public scenes so that a perceptive
audience could see the alienation of the leading
characters from the outside world. Their inner life
unfolds instead in domestic spaces and intimate
settings. But even here, away from the public eye,
out of earshot of the gossip-mongers, life is still
circumscribed by social convention. Marina Frolova-
Walker